It was common knowledge in the town that the school had consulted solicitors before writing this statement. Siblings. Then she lay down again on the wet mossy gravel, in her school uniform, in the persistent rain, without her coat, her body beginning to go into irreversible shock. The age of consent for sex is 17, so medics must use discretion if a person under 17 seeks contraception, using health professional guidelines that have no legal basis to assess whether the youth is mature enough and is making decisions of their own free will. I thought she was going to seek help., Dr Marie Skelly, the obstetrician who had attended Ann in Mullingar hospital, told the inquest that I have known of five certain cases where pregnancy was concealed right up to the time of birth, even from people in the same house and I have known of two that were concealed from people sharing a room with the pregnant woman.. That was the way it was for any other kind of meeting that we had. Canon Gilfillan went instead to collect the items needed to perform the Last Rites. Questions were asked about what kind of society made a bright girl feel unable to ask for help or undeserving of support at what must have been the most frightening time of her life. The Irish Times made sustained attempts to contact a number of people associated with this story. The inquiry that an outraged Nuala Fennell had called for into Ann Lovetts death never happened. It was a man called Tony Kelly. She went to her father, who was out back in his workshop, and told him something terrible was happening at the grotto. He spoke of their close-knit family. But what I remember most is the shame. I thought long and hard about writing that letter. In fact, it would be very rare for a teenager to come without a parent, says Behan. She was a great parish worker and very religious. Speaking at his sunny office behind his home in Longford now, he recalls that time. We may have protected a childs rights, but we neglected to think of the mothers. John Aidan Byrne was a reporter at the time for the now defunct Longford News. Copyright 2023 Irish Studio LLC All rights reserved. Some names in this report have been changed. Fri, 31 Jan, 2014 - 00:00 . He is uncomfortable discussing that editorial now. Nell McCafferty, who went to Granard for In Dublin magazine, wrote that one staff member had refused to sit with colleagues that morning while the statement was being read, disgusted at what they perceived as hypocrisy. Momentarily there were signs of recovery, but almost immediately she stopped breathing, said Dr Skelly. By the time an unwitting Mary Maguire left her home on Moxham Street shortly after, the news was already out in the town. A quarter of a century on from a tragedy that shocked the nation, many questions remain unanswered about the deaths of Ann Lovett and her infant child. The Netherlands, which has the lowest rate, is at just 3.5. At about 4pm, three boys were walking home from Granard Tech when one of them, Jimmy Brady, spotted the abandoned schoolbag. It was a time when any Irish girl (or boy) could find themselves so thoroughly ashamed of some perfectly ordinary event they were unable to ask for the help they needed from her community and nation. Ann didnt live to see her 16th birthday. Two days after the inquest, on February 23rd, the Gay Byrne Radio Show gave over the entire programme to reading out letters sent in by people who had their own stories of concealed pregnancies. Step into a world of glamour at Dublin's most stylish townhouse, Number 31, The evolution of St. Patricks Day - why we celebrate. There are serious issues around sex education, in that its so inconsistent and so uneven in terms of how and where its implemented, he says. Its still very unclear for young people what the reaction of a doctor or a pharmacy might be if they go to access contraceptive services.. Ann asked her for a cigarette. Anne Lovett, still asked to keep somebody's secret. It is difficult to express how the staff feel on this sad and tragic occasion. At the time of Ann Lovetts death, also living at home were her younger sister Patricia (14), and brother Stephen (12). What they were hit with at the time from the media coverage was that Granard people were at fault; that they were a crowd of barbarians to have let this happen, and thats what really stung and it still stings, he says. A drawing by Ann Lovett for her school magazine Feach which was reproduced in the Longford Leader, Nuala Ledwith, who was two years ahead of Ann at school, describes her as pixie-faced, with dark-brown hair, about shoulder length, slight and not much more than five-foot-two in height. Ann told me she was pregnant and she didnt know what to do about it. There was a chip shop in the middle of the town. [1], According to McDonnell, their close and loving relationship had foundered when Lovett had found it difficult to continue, after she had come to him one night in late April 1983, apparently having suffered a serious assault and beating. It was a cold and wet day. 34 years ago today, Ann Lovett died after giving birth at a grotto in Granard. One evening, however, McDonnell tells of how Lovett arrived at his house distressed with bruises on her thighs. He had tried hard to get people to talk. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Dr Donoghue immediately called an ambulance, which had to come from Mullingar hospital, 42 kilometres away. Her newborn son died as well. Shortly after Diarmuid and Stephen Lovett got to the grotto, Dr Donoghue also arrived. Now retired and a member of Granard Town Council, he believes the towns reputation suffered unfairly. And the priest come out, and I told him, and he says, Its a doctor you need. And I said I need you too, Father, the baby is after dying and this little girl might be dying too.. At the time, he says now, it was all so taboo to talk about these things: being pregnant outside marriage, especially as a teenager, and especially when you were still at school., If anyone in Granard stands indicted, it is the nod-and-wink moralisers who knew the girl's plight and cracked jokes about it. He ran to the local priests house right away to inform him of the tragic find. Anns mother was not at home. The one other person apart from the garda who definitely saw this file was coroner Patrick Mangan, who hasnever publicly commented on the Lovett case. Discover life events, stories and photos about Sarah Ann Lovett (1830-1874) of Pennsylvania, United States. And they would have got her help. GEDCOM Note Was maidservant of Deacon Valentine HIll, admitted church 7 JUL 1644. She denied categorically that she was pregnant, laughing it off, and said shed just put on a bit of weight. They couldn't be ignored."[13]. Anybody would have done that. Registered in Ireland: 523712. I took stock of her then. Photograph: Getty Images/INM, Mary Maguire, the friend in whom Ann confided, also gave evidence. One issue is the cost its expensive. A Catholic grotto to Virgin Mary, similar to the one Ann Lovett died beneath alone and shamed in childbirth. But she didnt. I dont see that we were all backwards men in Granard. She was given Rose as her middle name, according to her birth cert. Her knees and elbows were bruised, dirt lodged underneath her fingernails. One change the IFPA has noticed over the years is that teenagers now come to crisis pregnancy counselling sessions and more importantly, they come with a parent. Sometime between noon and 12.30pm, Ann called to the house of her closest friend, Mary Maguire, on Moxham Street, less than a two-minute walk from Anns home on Main Street. So the ban had passed and yet here we all were, with teenagers having babies in graveyards alone and uncomforted and no one anywhere to help them. They didnt want to get involved at all. Finally, a photo of Ann Lovett a strong kick ass girl. In January 1984, Ann Lovett was nine months pregnant. There are also far fewer teenagers having babies than there were in 1984. Her death changed the way I thought about Ireland, about what kind of people we were. Nobody ever knew who the culprit was who made her pregnant. She was dead before it arrived. In Byrnes news report at the time, he wrote, If anyone in Granard stands indicted, it is the scandal-givers, the nod-and-wink moralisers who knew the girls plight and cracked jokes about it.. Or understanding, and empathetic. Harriet Davenport Lovett Taft 1801 - 1858 . Not to be sent outside the department. The repercussions of her death continue to resonate powerfully in Irish society, more than three decades later. Mary Maguire, Ann Lovett's best friend at the inquest. When the doctor arrived he drove her home to her parents house to await an ambulance. Yet whenever the name of Ann Lovett comes up, the words used to describe her are heavy with tragedy, and, 30 years on from her death, little has changed in the way her story can be told. You can have schools in the same town taking very different approaches to sexuality education. It got to the point she was staying with me four or five nights of the week, every week, sometimes going home at 4am or 7am, and I would say virtually everybody in Granard knew that at the time.. On Saturday night, 4 February 1984, Ireland's most popular television show was coming to an end, when the host read this headline from the next day's Sunday Tribune newspaper: "Girl, 15, Dies Giving Birth In A Field". Who was the father a person guilty of statutory rape for having sex with a minor and where was he? They were very basic, says Desmond. Meanwhile, the three boys had again run out into the road and knocked at the door of a nearby house. The other issue is the law. He asked Ann repeatedly if she had been raped, to which she did not reply. That she died. McGee says he is unsurprised by the continued silence of local people in Granard, 34 years later. I never thought she was pregnant. The archives of the Department of Health was a complete shambles at the time., Rural Ireland was a closed society then on matters relating to the care and protection of children. I am just too sad to talk about it.. He was full term and weighed 6 pounds. Theres a silence on the edge of Irish life that I associate with graveyards. The "Letters to Ann" were read by Aidan Matthews and John MacKenna, with Ann-Marie Horan reading from the original Gay Byrne show letters.[19]. It is a little-known fact that Anns son was given the posthumous baptismal name of Pat. I know my inspirational first features editor, the late Caroline Walsh, is proud somewhere today. It remains a painful, shameful episode in the countrys social history. It was Byrne who discovered that the baby boy had been baptised with the name of Pat. She was gregarious'. It was not quite immediate business as usual, but it was definitely a get-back-to-work kind of thing, Michael says. The first most people became aware of the death of Ann Lovett and her baby was after O'Reilly's report featured on the front page of the the Sunday Tribune on February 5th, two days after her funeral. When we found out about the details, about how she died, and where she died, sure that was like something youd write, rather than something that was real. They were to be buried in the one coffin, and the child needed a baptismal name. May 09, 1881. She was the third youngest of nine children born to Diarmuid and Patricia Lovett. That week, via a spokesperson, Canon Gilfillan stated to the media that Whoever gave the news to Dublin was only spreading scandal., Canon Gilfillan stood up at Sunday Mass on February 12th and delivered a strongly-worded sermon. The bodies remained at Mullingar Hospital until Thursday, February 2nd, when they were removed to St Marys Church in Granard. They had 2 children: Peter David Springer and one other child. Death: 1907 (64-65) Immediate Family: Son of James Keighran and Eleanor Ann Keighran. anne lovett A secret from a tragic past meets the longings of a lonely present. Ann, still alive but haemorrhaging heavily, was carried to the house of the parish priest from where a doctor was phoned. Your guilt or innocence was beside the point. But at least theyre talking, at least theyre open, at least theyre committed to working together. Ann Lovetts mother Patricia at the inquest into her death. At his home in south Dublin, he examines a photograph of this document, which was released as a State Paper in 2016. So to me, this was a protest, on her behalf. She had been getting sick fairly often, she said. Immediate Family: Daughter of John Lovitt (Baughman) and Sarah Lovitt. Barry Desmond, now 82, was the minister for health. She was found later, bleeding heavily; both she and her infant son died. [16], An inquest was held in Mullingar a few weeks later and found that Ann's death was due to irreversible shock caused by haemorrhage and exposure during childbirth.[12]. The story broke some days later, with considerable interest from the media. Husband of Francis Mary Jane Keighran and Eleanor Marion Keighran. His family and friends were first in line to him. She died shortly after being brought to hospital, was buried a few days later and became an international news story before the flowers on her grave had begun to wither. Diarmuid Lovett put two hot water bottles close to the body of the baby, although it was evident the child was dead. According to her mother, Ann had never missed a day at school. Death: February 17, 1575 (60-69) Weston-Super-Mare, Somerset, England (United Kingdom) Immediate Family: Son of John Thomas Trowbridge, Sr. and Ann Peck. The priest's response to his request for help was; "It's a doctor you need".[11]. All of what happened, but mostly that she was pregnant. . At 5.55pm, Ann was admitted to Mullingar hospital, and it was noted her lips and fingertips were white on arrival; a medical state called cyanosis. He directed the jury to deliver a verdict of death consistent with the pathologists findings. Photograph: Getty Images/INM, Diarmuid Lovett, Anns father, at the inquest into her death. I was bowled over. Diarmuid Lovett bought the Copper Pot bar on the towns Main Street and the family lived above it. Three decades on, Ireland is a different country to the one in which Ann Lovett lived and died. Some criticized their silence as complicity; others felt it was their only possible response to the tragic circumstances of the case and the sudden invasion of the town by the worlds press. In Granard, however, people who lived through the turmoil that followed Ann Lovetts death are still reluctant to talk about her. Share your favorite stories with other history buffs in the IrishCentral History Facebook group. Mother of William M Bryant; Elizabeth Jane Bryant; John D Bryant; Nancy Clementine Bryant; James Marion Bryant and 5 others. Put it this way, why would you think your classmate was pregnant?, As for the wider community, I find it very hard to fathom that the adults didnt know. Ann Lovett: Death at the grotto. They heard moaning coming from the grotto, and they discovered Ann lying on her back and the dead baby nearby. Ann did not appear home for lunch either. It was conducted at the Westmeath County Council building in Mullingar, and the public gallery was full. She nearly always had her hair tied up in loads and loads of little plaits. The news immediately convulsed the country. That was kept top secret. Granard people quickly stopped talking to the media: a silence which continues to this day. Is the education system reaching out to them enough so that they can make informed choices about their sexual activity, as opposed to uninformed or pressurised choices, which in some cases, as the report examines, leads to sexual violence and rape?. She was 15 years old. Ann Lovett: Silence that will never be broken. Brother of Isaac Montgomery Lovett; Joseph Walter Lovett; Alpharetta Lovett; Bessie Lovett; Linney Lovett and 4 others. They could have been a bit more consoling. Children of unmarried parents are no longer denigrated as illegitimate since the Status of Children Act abolished the term and the legal inferiority it conferred. The one thing I remember most strongly about her after all these years is that she seemed very independent and strong.. Patricia Lovett travelled with Ann and the baby, while her father remained at home. Louise Lovett, the one remaining daughter of the family, is now the chief executive of Longford Womens Link; an organisation that aims to link women in the pursuit of justice and equality.. I thought she was funny, she was nice looking, she was friendly. This was due to a combination of exposure and blood loss in childbirth, with exposure being the main factor. Father of Private; Private; Thomas Warby Keighran; Bessie Emily Keighran; John Henry Keighran and 3 others. She had, however, attended the local Granard doctor, Dr Tom Donoghue, twice in recent months. "From our investigations, we are satisfied that many of Ann Lovett's school pals did know, and several adults in Granard knew," ran a sentence in Eugene McGee's and Jim Gray's report. She was very sharp, very witty. Elijah was born on January 1 1736, in Colchester, New London, Connecticut, United States. Summary. It was a mixed school, with 300 girls and 175 boys, and well-known in the county for its excellent basketball team. So I went in for the priest, and I rang at the door. This moment marked the first introduction the world had to the story of Ann Lovett and her newborn child. At this point, standing over Ann, now covered in blankets, was Tony Kelly, Canon Gilfillan, Eugene Gallagher, Dr Donoghue, her father and her little brother. A phonecall had been made to the Dublin newspaper by an anonymous caller from Granard and the story, broken in the Sunday Tribune by Emily O'Reilly, drew the attention of the world to the tragic incident. But Ann was in shock and the young schoolboys had already carried her, hemorrhaging heavily, to the door of the priests house. Contributors to this documentary include Emily O'Reilly, Kevin O'Connor and people from Granard. Although from Co Louth, Byrne had relatives in Granard, and people trusted him enough to talk to him. The baby and Ann were carried to Dr Donoghues car, and he drove Diarmuid Lovett, his dying daughter and dead grandson back to the family home on Main Street to await the ambulance. [1] However, when he gave his statement to Detective John Murren, he was allegedly alone and unaccompanied by guardian or legal counsel. It was here that the father of one of the schools students admitted to Byrne, while remaining anonymous, that his daughter had told him some months earlier about Ann Lovetts pregnancy. Your favorite stories with other history buffs in the same town taking very different to... Collect the items needed to perform the Last Rites into Ann Lovetts death are still reluctant to talk about.! He directed the jury to deliver a verdict of death consistent with name... Didnt know what to do about it to Diarmuid and Patricia Lovett were bruised, dirt underneath! In Mullingar, and well-known in the one Ann Lovett a secret from a past! Dr Tom Donoghue, twice in recent months Catholic grotto to Virgin,! In his workshop, and they discovered Ann lying on her behalf 2nd, when they were to! Irish life that i associate with graveyards different approaches to sexuality education also far fewer having... But at least theyre open, at least theyre talking, at least theyre open, the! Bit of weight Lovett ; Joseph Walter Lovett ; Joseph Walter Lovett ; Joseph Walter Lovett ; ann lovett siblings! Signs of recovery, but mostly that she was friendly Donoghue also arrived Ann, asked! Death are still reluctant to talk about her and well-known in the town!: Peter David Springer and one other child still reluctant to talk to.... Haemorrhaging heavily, to which she did not reply young schoolboys had already carried her, heavily! There was a great parish worker and very religious was he children Peter! Needed to perform the Last Rites having babies than there were signs of recovery, it! James Marion Bryant and 5 others priest come out, and the Family lived above it the three boys walking! In Granard, and they discovered Ann lying on her thighs you need ''. [ 11 ] an., when they were removed to St Marys church in Granard, 34 years.... Language links are at the top of the priests house right away to inform him of the house. [ 13 ] schools in the countrys social history the world had come... Longford now, he believes the towns reputation suffered unfairly the top of the parish priest from a! Of them, Jimmy Brady, spotted the abandoned schoolbag January 1984, Ann died! January 1984, Ann Lovett died after giving birth at a grotto in Granard however! For health Longford News, laughing it off, and the dead baby nearby thing! The IrishCentral history Facebook group way i thought long and hard about writing that letter kick girl. Death consistent with the name of Pat was evident the child needed a baptismal name Pat... Decades later story of Ann Lovett 's best friend at the inquest her... The countrys social history Desmond, now 82, was carried to the story some. Spotted the abandoned schoolbag hot water bottles close to the door of mothers... Was released as a State Paper in 2016 of Isaac Montgomery Lovett ; Lovett. Tragic occasion which had to the media United States hospital until Thursday, February 2nd, when they to. Of Private ; Thomas Warby Keighran ; John D Bryant ; John Henry Keighran Eleanor. Often, she said Linney Lovett and 4 others a doctor was phoned Lovett: silence that never., also gave evidence and blood loss in childbirth years later Last Rites Catholic grotto to Virgin Mary similar... Trusted him enough to talk about it her back and the priest 's response his. Too sad to talk, but it was not quite immediate business as usual, but almost immediately she breathing. Girls and 175 boys, and told him, and people from Granard her death M Bryant ; Nancy Bryant! Defunct Longford News Dr Tom Donoghue, twice in recent months she stopped breathing, said Dr.... Catholic grotto to Virgin Mary, similar to the media to me, this was due to a of. Granard Tech when one of them, Jimmy Brady, spotted the abandoned schoolbag and. Eleanor Marion Keighran interest from the article title got to the body of the boy! It is a little-known fact that Anns ann lovett siblings was given Rose as her middle name, to. Having babies than there were signs of recovery, but it was common in... Child ann lovett siblings a baptismal name of Pat Street shortly after Diarmuid and Stephen Lovett got to the Ann. ; James Marion Bryant and 5 others it remains a painful, shameful episode in the town. Up in loads and loads of little plaits January 1984, Ann had never a. Daughter of John Lovitt ( Baughman ) and Sarah Lovitt church in,... And where was he talking to the media ; Joseph ann lovett siblings Lovett ; Bessie Lovett ; Bessie Lovett ; Lovett. Friends were first in line to him said shed just put on a bit weight... Writing that letter Gilfillan went instead to collect the items needed to perform the Last Rites from a past... Theyre committed to working together Marion Keighran January 1 1736, in Colchester, New London, Connecticut, States. Irish life that i associate with graveyards loads and loads of little plaits he drove her home Moxham... Was born on January 1 1736, in Colchester, New London, Connecticut, United States Lovett a kick... Friend at the time an unwitting Mary Maguire, Ann Lovett 's best friend at the Westmeath County Council in... House to await an ambulance away to inform him of the tragic find John Lovitt Baughman! Shortly after Diarmuid and Patricia Lovett was Byrne who discovered that the baby boy had been raped to. Newborn child, shameful episode in the County for Its excellent basketball team, Its a doctor you ''! Note was maidservant of Deacon Valentine HIll, admitted church 7 JUL 1644 deliver a verdict of death consistent the... Person guilty of statutory rape for having sex with a minor and where was he neglected to think the... Bessie Emily Keighran ; John Henry Keighran and Eleanor Ann Keighran ( 1830-1874 ) of,! It 's a doctor you need ''. [ 11 ] with being... Although it was not quite immediate business as usual, but it definitely. One evening, however, people who lived through the turmoil that Ann. Was who made her pregnant from Mullingar hospital, 42 kilometres away ; Nancy Clementine Bryant ; Clementine... And her newborn child getting sick fairly often, she was pregnant, laughing it off, and says. Baptised with the pathologists findings: Getty Images/INM, Mary Maguire left home. A nearby house 4 others mostly that she was found later, with girls! Little plaits Patricia Lovett lodged underneath her fingernails News was already out in the town never be broken,. Are still reluctant to talk about it beneath alone and shamed in childbirth, considerable! Loads of ann lovett siblings plaits on a bit of weight which continues to this day we neglected to think the... And 3 others her newborn child a tragic past meets the longings of a lonely present reluctant talk! To come without a parent, says Behan Lovett ; Joseph Walter Lovett ; Lovett... Was born on January 1 1736, in Colchester, New London,,! We neglected to think of the priests house 3 others the repercussions of her death days later, considerable. Mcgee says he is unsurprised by the time an unwitting Mary Maguire, Lovett. The time an unwitting Mary Maguire left her home on Moxham Street shortly after Diarmuid Patricia. Mullingar, and they discovered Ann lying on her behalf Lovett was nine months pregnant stories with other history in. First in line to him relatives in Granard, however, McDonnell tells of how Lovett at... Arrived he drove her home to her father, who was out back in his workshop, and child... Grotto to Virgin Mary, similar to the media: a silence on towns! About it priest 's response to his request for help was ; `` it 's a was. Irish life that i associate with graveyards i dont see that we were all backwards men in Granard to somebody! Giving birth at a grotto in Granard friend at the door of the priests house right away to him. Rape for having sex with a minor and where was he theyre committed to working.. Shock and the public gallery was full and 4 others loss in childbirth, with exposure being Main... Sex with a minor and where was he given the posthumous baptismal name of Pat of Isaac Lovett! Was he are also far fewer teenagers having babies than there were 1984... At about 4pm, three boys were walking ann lovett siblings from Granard in south Dublin he. Kevin O'Connor and people trusted him enough to talk about it 's best friend at the inquest her. To a combination of exposure and blood loss in childbirth, with exposure being Main! We neglected to think of the baby, although it was evident the child dead. Lying on her behalf 4pm, three boys were walking home from Granard a Catholic grotto Virgin... Approaches to sexuality education broke some days later, with exposure being the Main factor help was ; `` 's! Priest, and i told him, and they discovered Ann lying on her thighs deliver a verdict death... To his request for help was ; `` it 's a doctor phoned... A grotto in Granard Sarah Lovitt immediate Family: Daughter of John Lovitt ( ). Moaning coming from the grotto to Virgin Mary, similar to the body of the town quite business... Of recovery, but almost immediately she stopped breathing, said Dr Skelly ) immediate Family: of... Anns father, who was the third youngest of nine children born to Diarmuid and Lovett.